The same cubic meter of CLT can yield very different results in an LCA, depending on what is assumed to happen to it after demolition.
Each EPD proposes its own end-of-life scenario, which may not match what is actually planned for the building. Anyone comparing products or building systems without examining the scenarios assumed by the supplier risks comparing the data incorrectly.
End-of-life scenarios in fact carry significant weight when analyzing CLT across phases A1-D.
To understand how much weight they carry, we analyzed twelve EPDs from eleven European CLT manufacturers, all compliant with EN 15804+A2.
The end-of-life modules
| Module | What it includes |
| C1 | Deconstruction or demolition |
| C2 | Transport to waste treatment |
| C3 | Treatment for reuse, recycling or energy recovery; this is where biogenic carbon exits the system |
| C4 | Final disposal, for example landfill |
| D | Benefits and loads beyond the system boundary: material and energy that replace other sources; must always be reported separately |
What European CLT manufacturers’ EPDs declare
The first finding: the main scenario is almost always the same. In the vast majority of EPDs, end-of-life CLT is incinerated with energy recovery, at 95-100%.
Only a few manufacturers use a mix including shares of recycling and reuse. The clearest case is Derix, which declares an EPD for panels sold under a take-back contract: 60% is reused and only 34% incinerated.
The second important aspect to analyze is how much the entire life cycle of the panel weighs, in terms of fossil emissions: from production to demolition.
The chart sums the production modules (A1-A3) and the end-of-life modules (C1-C4).

From production to demolition, 1 m³ of CLT emits between 52 and 137 kg of fossil CO₂, depending on the manufacturer.
The end-of-life share ranges from a few kilograms to over 30: here too, the assumptions each EPD makes about the treatment plant have a significant effect.
Same CLT, different end-of-life
Some EPDs declare, in addition to the main scenario (incineration), alternative scenarios such as recycling, reuse or transport to landfill.
The environmental impact related to the product and production stages is identical, while the process following demolition changes.

The same comparison appears in KLH’s EPD: with incineration, CLT is worth 109 kg CO₂e/m³ without module D and −153 with module D; with reuse, 90 and +13.
Three things emerge.
1. Landfill is by far the worst scenario. Timber that decomposes in the absence of oxygen produces methane, a greenhouse gas more potent than CO₂. In Stora Enso’s EPD, the biogenic carbon released in landfill amounts to 1,010 kg CO₂e, more than the 762 kg stored: the balance does not return to zero but worsens by 248 kg.
2. Without module D, reuse wins; with module D, incineration wins. Looking at production and end-of-life alone, reuse is the best scenario, because it avoids combustion emissions. Once module D is added, the ranking reverses: incineration receives a credit for the energy produced, which replaces fossil sources, while reuse only receives credit for the new CLT that is avoided. Adding module D to the result inadvertently rewards the scenario that releases carbon back into the atmosphere immediately.
3. Reuse receives no credit for the carbon that remains stored in the timber. Even when CLT is reused, EPDs remove the biogenic carbon from the balance in module C3: the value of a second life does not appear in any module. This approach clearly reveals a contradiction and a lack of a regulatory tool to reward it.
Module D depends on the energy being replaced
In the main incineration scenarios, module D ranges from −26 to −410 kg CO₂e/m³: it varies by more than fifteen times for the same operation, burning timber at end of life. The difference does not depend on the product, but on which energy source is assumed to be replaced.

Contexts where the electricity grid is highly decarbonized, such as Norway, are “penalized” compared to grids tied to fossil sources, such as Italy’s.
The overall A1-D cycle
Adding together production, end-of-life and module D, the ranking reverses. Rubner, which has the highest fossil footprint, becomes the second-best result, at −273 kg CO₂e/m³, thanks to the credit for replaced energy.
Splitkon and Derix, which instead replace energy that is already renewable or burn only part of the timber, are the only ones with a positive balance.

The chart does not indicate which CLT is better; it simply reports data, which must be carefully evaluated.
We have seen how the end-of-life scenario adopted and the national energy context can, in fact, favor products with a greater fossil impact on the environment, thanks to incineration and favorable energy conditions.
Reuse is undervalued
Under EN 15804, biogenic carbon exits the system at C3 even when the panel is reused: it passes to the next product, which will count it as its own. Reuse retains only the module D credit for the new CLT that does not need to be produced, which is small because producing CLT emits little fossil CO₂.
In Stora Enso’s EPD, this is worth 46 kg CO₂e/m³, compared to 268 for incineration.
To give value to reuse, storage time would need to be taken into account: one tonne of CO₂ kept stored in timber for another 50 years is not equivalent to one tonne released back into the atmosphere immediately.
A method for doing this was proposed in 2024 by Wageningen University & Research, commissioned by the Dutch government: we describe it in Biogenic carbon: why storage time matters.
The energy credit looks to the past
Module D assumes that the energy obtained from timber replaces today’s energy mix. But a panel installed today will be demolished in 50 or 100 years, when grids will be far more decarbonized, and the replaced energy will be worth much less. Norway already shows how the calculation changes: with a grid that is almost entirely renewable, Splitkon’s module D is worth −26 kg CO₂e/m³, fifteen times less than Rubner’s.
With a decarbonized grid, the advantage of incineration shrinks almost to the point of disappearing, and reuse becomes the best scenario even when module D is included.
What this means for designers
- Choose the building’s end-of-life scenario, rather than inheriting the one in the EPD.
- Compare products and building systems only under the same end-of-life scenario.
- Keep module D separate, stating which replaced energy source it is calculated on and how it would change with a decarbonized grid.
- Make reuse credible from the design stage: demountable mechanical connections, identifiable elements, a deconstruction plan. Some manufacturers, such as Derix, already offer panel take-back contracts.
Want to compare the end-of-life scenarios of your structure?
We model them explicitly in the LCA analysis of timber buildings, together with the construction details for disassembly in DfMA design.





























