Category: Technical insights

In this space, we share some of our specific technical insights, reflections on particular topics, or in-depth analyses: LCA, BIM, moisture management, DfMA, and FEM.

  • End-of-life of timber in LCA: comparing CLT EPD scenarios

    End-of-life of timber in LCA: comparing CLT EPD scenarios

    The same cubic meter of CLT can yield very different results in an LCA, depending on what is assumed to happen to it after demolition.

    Each EPD proposes its own end-of-life scenario, which may not match what is actually planned for the building. Anyone comparing products or building systems without examining the scenarios assumed by the supplier risks comparing the data incorrectly.

    End-of-life scenarios in fact carry significant weight when analyzing CLT across phases A1-D.

    To understand how much weight they carry, we analyzed twelve EPDs from eleven European CLT manufacturers, all compliant with EN 15804+A2.

    The end-of-life modules

    ModuleWhat it includes
    C1Deconstruction or demolition
    C2Transport to waste treatment
    C3Treatment for reuse, recycling or energy recovery; this is where biogenic carbon exits the system
    C4Final disposal, for example landfill
    DBenefits and loads beyond the system boundary: material and energy that replace other sources; must always be reported separately

    What European CLT manufacturers’ EPDs declare

    The first finding: the main scenario is almost always the same. In the vast majority of EPDs, end-of-life CLT is incinerated with energy recovery, at 95-100%.

    Only a few manufacturers use a mix including shares of recycling and reuse. The clearest case is Derix, which declares an EPD for panels sold under a take-back contract: 60% is reused and only 34% incinerated.

    The second important aspect to analyze is how much the entire life cycle of the panel weighs, in terms of fossil emissions: from production to demolition.

    The chart sums the production modules (A1-A3) and the end-of-life modules (C1-C4).

    End-of-life_CLT_overall_cycle_A1-C3

    From production to demolition, 1 m³ of CLT emits between 52 and 137 kg of fossil CO₂, depending on the manufacturer.

    The end-of-life share ranges from a few kilograms to over 30: here too, the assumptions each EPD makes about the treatment plant have a significant effect.

    Same CLT, different end-of-life

    Some EPDs declare, in addition to the main scenario (incineration), alternative scenarios such as recycling, reuse or transport to landfill.

    The environmental impact related to the product and production stages is identical, while the process following demolition changes.

    CLT_end-of-life_scenarios

    The same comparison appears in KLH’s EPD: with incineration, CLT is worth 109 kg CO₂e/m³ without module D and −153 with module D; with reuse, 90 and +13.

    Three things emerge.

    1. Landfill is by far the worst scenario. Timber that decomposes in the absence of oxygen produces methane, a greenhouse gas more potent than CO₂. In Stora Enso’s EPD, the biogenic carbon released in landfill amounts to 1,010 kg CO₂e, more than the 762 kg stored: the balance does not return to zero but worsens by 248 kg.

    2. Without module D, reuse wins; with module D, incineration wins. Looking at production and end-of-life alone, reuse is the best scenario, because it avoids combustion emissions. Once module D is added, the ranking reverses: incineration receives a credit for the energy produced, which replaces fossil sources, while reuse only receives credit for the new CLT that is avoided. Adding module D to the result inadvertently rewards the scenario that releases carbon back into the atmosphere immediately.

    3. Reuse receives no credit for the carbon that remains stored in the timber. Even when CLT is reused, EPDs remove the biogenic carbon from the balance in module C3: the value of a second life does not appear in any module. This approach clearly reveals a contradiction and a lack of a regulatory tool to reward it.

    Module D depends on the energy being replaced

    In the main incineration scenarios, module D ranges from −26 to −410 kg CO₂e/m³: it varies by more than fifteen times for the same operation, burning timber at end of life. The difference does not depend on the product, but on which energy source is assumed to be replaced.

    End-of-life_CLT_overall_cycle_D

    Contexts where the electricity grid is highly decarbonized, such as Norway, are “penalized” compared to grids tied to fossil sources, such as Italy’s.

    The overall A1-D cycle

    Adding together production, end-of-life and module D, the ranking reverses. Rubner, which has the highest fossil footprint, becomes the second-best result, at −273 kg CO₂e/m³, thanks to the credit for replaced energy.

    Splitkon and Derix, which instead replace energy that is already renewable or burn only part of the timber, are the only ones with a positive balance.

    End-of-life_CLT_overall_cycle_A1-D

    The chart does not indicate which CLT is better; it simply reports data, which must be carefully evaluated.

    We have seen how the end-of-life scenario adopted and the national energy context can, in fact, favor products with a greater fossil impact on the environment, thanks to incineration and favorable energy conditions.

    Reuse is undervalued

    Under EN 15804, biogenic carbon exits the system at C3 even when the panel is reused: it passes to the next product, which will count it as its own. Reuse retains only the module D credit for the new CLT that does not need to be produced, which is small because producing CLT emits little fossil CO₂.

    In Stora Enso’s EPD, this is worth 46 kg CO₂e/m³, compared to 268 for incineration.

    To give value to reuse, storage time would need to be taken into account: one tonne of CO₂ kept stored in timber for another 50 years is not equivalent to one tonne released back into the atmosphere immediately.

    A method for doing this was proposed in 2024 by Wageningen University & Research, commissioned by the Dutch government: we describe it in Biogenic carbon: why storage time matters.

    The energy credit looks to the past

    Module D assumes that the energy obtained from timber replaces today’s energy mix. But a panel installed today will be demolished in 50 or 100 years, when grids will be far more decarbonized, and the replaced energy will be worth much less. Norway already shows how the calculation changes: with a grid that is almost entirely renewable, Splitkon’s module D is worth −26 kg CO₂e/m³, fifteen times less than Rubner’s.

    With a decarbonized grid, the advantage of incineration shrinks almost to the point of disappearing, and reuse becomes the best scenario even when module D is included.

    What this means for designers

    1. Choose the building’s end-of-life scenario, rather than inheriting the one in the EPD.
    2. Compare products and building systems only under the same end-of-life scenario.
    3. Keep module D separate, stating which replaced energy source it is calculated on and how it would change with a decarbonized grid.
    4. Make reuse credible from the design stage: demountable mechanical connections, identifiable elements, a deconstruction plan. Some manufacturers, such as Derix, already offer panel take-back contracts.

    Want to compare the end-of-life scenarios of your structure?

    We model them explicitly in the LCA analysis of timber buildings, together with the construction details for disassembly in DfMA design.

  • Biogenic carbon in timber buildings: how to read it in an LCA

    Biogenic carbon in timber buildings: how to read it in an LCA

    “A timber building has zero impact,” or even “carbon negative.” This is a claim often seen, and one we treat with caution. Timber does genuinely store carbon, but that benefit is conditional and temporary. Understanding how it is accounted for is the first step to correctly reading an LCA for a timber building, and to avoid promising clients something that cannot be substantiated.

    What is biogenic carbon

    As a tree grows, it absorbs CO₂ from the atmosphere and fixes the carbon in its wood. When that wood becomes a beam or a panel, the carbon remains stored in the product. This is biogenic carbon: of biological origin, distinct from the fossil carbon emitted to produce energy, transport materials, or process them.

    Biogenic carbon does not disappear. It remains in the building for as long as the timber stays in use, and is then released back into the atmosphere if the timber is burned or decomposes.

    How much CO₂ is in one cubic metre of timber

    Dry timber is roughly half carbon by mass. EN 16449 provides the calculation method: the dry mass is multiplied by the carbon fraction (0.5) and by 44/12, the ratio between the molecular mass of CO₂ and that of carbon.

    where c_f = 0.5 is the carbon fraction, ρ_ω is the density at moisture content ω, and V_ω is the volume. The result therefore depends mainly on density:

    ProductDensityBiogenic carbonCO₂ stored
    Spruce (dry timber)411 kg/m³205 kg C/m³≈ 750 kg CO₂/m³
    Softwood glued laminated timber (from EPD)464 kg/m³208 kg C/m³≈ 763 kg CO₂/m³
    Beech LVL (from EPD)800 kg/m³365 kg C/m³≈ 1,339 kg CO₂/m³

    As a first approximation, then, one cubic metre of structural softwood timber stores around three-quarters of a tonne of CO₂. This is the same value found, with a negative sign, in the biogenic GWP of modules A1–A3 in EPDs.

    How the standard accounts for it: the “-1/+1” method

    EN 15804+A2, the reference standard for environmental product declarations, accounts for biogenic carbon at two points:

    • during production (modules A1–A3), CO₂ absorption is entered as a negative value;
    • at end of life (modules C3–C4), the same carbon leaves the system, either as an emission or as a flow to the next product, and is entered as a positive value.

    Over the entire life cycle, the two terms balance out. This is the meaning of the “loan”: the benefit of timber only appears if the assessment stops at the production modules.

    This does not mean that storage has no value. A tonne of CO₂ returned to the atmosphere after 50 or 100 years produces, in the meantime, less warming than a tonne emitted today.

    Current rules do not account for this time effect: it is a topic we will explore further in a dedicated article.

    Why “stopping at A1–A3” is misleading in the LCA of a timber building

    An analysis that reports only modules A1 to A3 shows very low or negative GWP values for timber. This is correct, but partial. Once modules C are included, biogenic carbon re-enters the balance and timber’s apparent advantage is scaled back.

    The table above provides an example. Beech LVL stores almost twice the CO₂ of glued laminated timber per cubic metre, but according to the same EPDs it has a fossil production impact around 3.5 times higher. Looking only at the biogenic figure, it would seem the “greener” product; looking at the fossil figure, the opposite is true.

    The correct comparison, moreover, should be made on the basis of equal performance rather than equal volume: a stronger product may require smaller cross-sections.

    Reading GWP broken down

    EN 15804+A2 breaks GWP down into three indicators:

    IndicatorWhat it measuresWhy it matters
    GWP-fossilEmissions from fossil sources: energy, transport, processesThis is the part that is not offset: it is the real production impact
    GWP-biogenicAbsorption and release of biogenic carbonShows how much carbon is stored and when it is released
    GWP-lulucEffects of land use and land use changeFlags supply chains linked to deforestation or land use change

    The chart below shows the declared values for the A1-A3 production phase from the EPDs of seven European CLT manufacturers.

    biogenic-carbon-CLT-timber-panels

    The stored biogenic carbon (GWP-Biogenic) is almost the same for all products, between 756 and 803 kg CO₂e/m³, since it depends on the amount of timber in the panel.

    GWP-fossil, on the other hand, varies by nearly three times, from 45 to 132 kg CO₂e/m³, depending on the energy used in the plant, the electricity mix, the share of transport during production, and the adhesives used.

    GWP-luluc is negligible, under 2 kg.

    The result is that total GWP values are all strongly negative and very similar to one another, ranging from −720 to −624 kg CO₂e/m³.

    A low total GWP can conceal a high GWP-fossil, offset by the biogenic component. In our reports, the three values are always presented separately.

    End of life determines where the carbon goes

    With the -1/+1 method, biogenic carbon always leaves the building’s balance at end of life. What happens to it afterwards depends on the scenario chosen:

    • incineration with energy recovery, the most common scenario in EPDs: the carbon returns to the atmosphere in module C3, and module D credits the energy produced, which displaces fossil sources;
    • landfill: the timber degrades slowly and only partially; the standard requires these emissions to be calculated in C4 with no time limit;
    • reuse or recycling: the carbon passes to the next product and storage continues.

    The EPDs we analysed assume incineration as the predominant end-of-life scenario.

    For one cubic metre of softwood glued laminated timber, the biogenic GWP in C3 is +767 kg CO₂e and module D is −416 kg CO₂e; for beech LVL, +1,340 and −618. Module D may seem like a further advantage, but it assumes the timber is burned: the opposite of extending the loan.

    A full comparison between the end-of-life scenarios of different EPDs is available in Timber end of life: how EPD scenarios change the balance.


    Do you need to understand the biogenic carbon impact of your project? Would you like preliminary data to help choose the structural system that best optimizes the LCA impact?

    We invite you to visit our LCA analysis of timber buildings page, where you can also access further sources for updates.

  • Economic Optimization of Platform-Frame Timber Structures Through Numerical Modeling

    Economic Optimization of Platform-Frame Timber Structures Through Numerical Modeling

    Very often our clients ask us to proceed with the optimization of platform-frame timber construction systems, especially for large-scale projects.

    In the field of platform-frame timber structures, given the base dimensions of the module and sheathing panels, optimization necessarily focuses on connection systems.

    The first step is to analyze the individual module to obtain information on its deformability and resistance as the connection system varies.

    Description of a “typical” analyzed module

    The following presents results for a “typical” frame measuring 2800x1250mm constructed with 80x200mm profiles in glulam C24.

    On both sides, 10mm thick OSB3 sheets are applied (analyses were performed with different thicknesses and using single panels, which are not reported herein).

    The sheet/frame connection was designed using the following fasteners:

    • staples G 1.6x32mm;
    • Ring nails strip P34° 2.8x64mm;
    • Anker nails strip P34° 4x40mm;
    • screws HZB 4x40mm.

    FEM Modeling of Platform-Frame Timber Frame

    Frame elements are used to model the frame members, while shell elements are used for the sheets.

    The connections were modeled with linear elastic link elements having stiffness equal to that calculable using the formulas in section 7.1 of UNI EN 1995-1-1.

    The module is constrained to the ground at the two lower extremities with a roller and a hinge.

    A force of 10 kN was applied at the upper vertex to enable displacement verification.

    The material behavior was assumed to be linear elastic.

    Results and Comparative Numerical Analyses

    Numerical analyses were performed to evaluate the maximum displacement of the timber frame wall as both the connection type and spacing varied.

    The numerical result was compared with the analytical result obtained using the following formulation*:

    In this formula, the displacement of the control point is given by the sum of the shear deformation contribution of the sheathing panel, the panel/frame connection system, the shear slip of the angle brackets, the slip of the hold-downs, and finally the compression deformation of the frame.

    In this case, only the first two contributions were considered.

    The results obtained are presented below.

    Subsequently, we calculate the mechanical resistance associated with the different connection types using the analytical formulation of Method A in section 9.2.4.2 of UNI EN 1995-1-1.

    Finally, a cost analysis of the individual fasteners was performed using the price list of a well-known hardware supplier.

    Based on these results, it is possible to decide with the client the most advantageous connection system from both a performance and economic standpoint.

    The choice of connection system must be made on a case-by-case basis because it is influenced by the stresses acting on the walls, their geometry, and the inter-story deformations to be ensured (considering that the deformation contributions of the ground connection systems must be added).

    Once the connection system is defined, the equivalent stiffness of the individual wall module is obtained to enable modeling through links.

    With the computational burden for wall modeling reduced, it is possible to proceed with the modeling and optimization of module-to-module connections.

    * Structural behavior of timber framed buildings, Tiziano Sartori, 2012

    Assignment: Economic Optimization of Platform-Frame Timber Structures Through Numerical Modeling

    If you are looking for a firm capable of managing prototypes, performing specialized modeling, or optimizing complex structures, contact us!

  • Studiofornale.it in the ANCE national magazine: our seismic retrofitting project selected

    Studiofornale.it in the ANCE national magazine: our seismic retrofitting project selected

    An article regarding a seismic retrofitting project designed by us in the province of Modena appeared in November in the magazine “Rassegna tecnologica” No. 9 of the National Association of Building Contractors (ANCE).

    The article describes the technique used for the seismic retrofitting of the building, which was severely damaged by the 2012 earthquake.

    The article describes the intervention methods proposed and implemented on the timber floors; further interventions on the building can be found in this post.

    For those interested in learning more, the link to the full post is provided below:

    By clicking on this link, you can access the section featuring some of our seismic improvement and retrofitting projects.

    Please contact us if you would like to learn more or submit a property for seismic retrofitting or improvement.

  • Improvement of Seismic Behavior of Wooden Floors in Existing Structures

    Improvement of Seismic Behavior of Wooden Floors in Existing Structures

    We provide the link to the online magazine INGENIO-WEB, which recently published an article dedicated to one of our projects.

    Learn more

    This concerns the intervention on wooden floors carried out as part of the seismic upgrade project for a building damaged by the Emilia Romagna earthquake in 2012.

    In collaboration with Eng. Valeria Rizzotti, we handled the structural design of the seismic upgrade with particular attention to the reinforcement of the existing wooden floors, which had both limited load-bearing capacity and high in-plane deformability.

    The intervention aimed to upgrade the floor’s load-bearing capacity to meet required loads, increase its in-plane stiffness, and ensure proper connection/anchorage to the masonry walls.

    If you are interested in this topic, here is the link.

    If you need to seismically improve your building, do not hesitate to contact us for a consultation!

  • Reinforcement and consolidation of solid wood floors in the province of Modena

    Reinforcement and consolidation of solid wood floors in the province of Modena

    Fornale Engineering, in collaboration with Eng. Valeria Rizzotti, handled the structural design of the reinforcement and consolidation intervention of the wooden floors of the former nursery school in Staggia (MO), which was hit by the 2012 Emilia earthquake.

    The floor intervention is part of the seismic retrofitting works of the entire building; however, due to the particular nature of the intervention methods, we have decided to dedicate a post to the floor retrofitting.

    The particular nature of this intervention arises from the need to preserve the soffits of the existing floors, which featured culturally significant frescoes under protection by the Superintendence.

    The proposed intervention included the following phases:

    1. removal of the existing flooring/planking to expose the load-bearing structure;
    2. at the trimming beams, the ends of the secondary joists resting on them were cut, and these were end-anchored to the existing beam with metal brackets;
    3. on the top of the trimming beams, HEA steel beams were placed, sized to carry the full live load of the new floor while ensuring very small mid-span deflections;
    4. new load-bearing wooden beams were inserted on the lower flange of the beam, onto which the loads of the new floor would be applied;
    5. an OSB3 planking was laid, cut and nailed so that the edges aligned with the axes of the new underlying beams;
    6. crossed perforated straps were laid, whose ends along the load-bearing walls and at the ends were welded to threaded rods passing through the thickness of the masonry. In this way, a considerable in-plane stiffening was achieved, also given the reduced spacing of the cross straps at 45 degrees;
    7. from the outside, niches were carved into the wall thickness of sufficient size to allow the placement of a steel plate and the tightening bolt of the rods, which enabled tensioning of the perforated straps;
    8. a second cross-laid OSB planking was laid;
    9. laying of a polyethylene sheet for the subsequent screed pour and simultaneous placement of the local typical brick tiles.

    In this way, it was possible to safeguard the areas of the building with frescoed floors while ensuring, on the other hand, the necessary load-bearing capacity with adequate in-plane stiffness.

    In the areas where the floor was destroyed due to the collapse of the roof, we built new floors from scratch using the same technique so that the cross-strapping would be uniform over the entire surface.

    On both floors of the building, which spans about 235 sqm, it was decided to work with the straps and OSB planking to ensure uniform stiffness.

    Assignment: Executive co-design of wooden structures

    more information

  • Consolidation of a damaged timber beam with metal counterbracing

    Consolidation of a damaged timber beam with metal counterbracing

    Studiofornalè handled the structural design for the consolidation of this 15th-century beam located inside a residential building and supporting a residential floor.

    The beam, with a 18x56cm cross-section, is composed of 3 trapezoidal timber beams that work together through notches and metal wedges.

    It is interesting to note that based on these early experiences with composite beams, the use of timber for long spans was progressively refined (see Leonardo in the 16th century, del Rosso in the 18th century) until the birth of modern glued laminated timber (1905 with the Hetzer patent).

    The beam, 8.7 m long, was fractured at a knot on the intrados near a wedge, and this imperfection was likely the cause of the crack and the resulting flexural deformation of the beam, which reaches 15 cm (L/58).

    The planned intervention consists of installing a metal counterbracing system in which the vertical part is used as a jack that, after tensioning the bar system, rotates on the axis of the vertical hubs to “lift” the beam and close the crack.

    All metal components were manufactured from high-strength steel; the forks and locknuts were machined on a CNC work center while the plates were plasma-cut.

    Assignment: Executive design of timber structures, construction supervision

    more information